13 Comments
User's avatar
Melinda Rackham's avatar

appreciate this post - and the lost atlas of belonging has to be your next book title !

Expand full comment
Dr Barbara Sumner's avatar

that's a rather nice idea. You never know.

Expand full comment
Melinda Rackham's avatar

too good to not do :)

Expand full comment
Sarah Wilshaw-Sparkes's avatar

Love this piece. What a brilliant analogy 'palimpsest' is for the lived reality of an adoptee. The law scrapes off any visible trace of the original writings to create a tabula rasa, and the new family overwrites it with their own drama. The first ink remains, indelible yet invisible.

The problem, as you point out, is that when Self/Soul responds to the first ink and is drawn to Sport X or Creative Y, the adoptee has no idea if it's a whim or a calling. I've been drawn to story and words all my life, but I was nearly 40 before I learned that pull was written in first ink.

Expand full comment
Dr Barbara Sumner's avatar

“…when Self/Soul responds to the first ink and is drawn to Sport X or Creative Y, the adoptee has no idea if it's a whim or a calling.”

Is it a whim or a calling? THAT is the most perfect description. It is the question I’ve asked for so much of my life.

Expand full comment
Terri's avatar

As soon as your post came through, it was yet another must now read. I appreciate your narrative and willingness to share your story. 💗

Expand full comment
Diana Dunning's avatar

This is so helpful Barbara. Talking about skills that would have been helpful. Growing up I stayed close to my almost twin brother (5 m diff) and acquiesced to his and my mum's authority and opinion that continued well into adulthood.

Expand full comment
Josie O. Pearse's avatar

Beautiful descriptions of severance. There’s something rhythmic and searching about your prose that rings true for this adoptee.

Expand full comment
Dr Barbara Sumner's avatar

What a lovely thing to say, thank you.

Expand full comment
Saskia Pierre's avatar

As an adoptee I absolutely adore your writing. It makes me feel so seen and understood❤️

Expand full comment
Dr Barbara Sumner's avatar

That is the best compliment. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Jean Shea's avatar

Love your writing and observations. It’s helped to put definition on so much of what I, as an adoptee, have felt and experienced. I am proud of my adoptive family’s history and my birth family’s story, but neither are mine. I have often observed that i am a member of a culture of one. Glad to have found your substack.

Expand full comment
Dr Barbara Sumner's avatar

You are so welcome here. And there are so many of us, you are in a culture of multitudes, and many of us are in a process to unravel our imposed identities and the meaning of it all.

Expand full comment